Zina Sanchez: Thanks for the review!! Very helpful!
Brendan Hinds: Neither are good enough. I want something that also records heart rate
along with movement as that is a FAR better indicator for sleep/step
tracking. Simply relying on an accelerometer for steps and sleep tracking
is soooooo inaccurate. A device which takes measurements throughout the
course of the first 72 hours of use and then uses averages based on time of
day, using that collated data to give accurate activity information for the
particular person would be WAY better.
Vasco Feeney: have you seen razor nabu? they say its good
Knut-Henning Tønnessen: Thanks Jason. I've ordered 2 of these for me and my girlfriend :)
playmeagain: my jawbone broke twice and waiting for another one but i am watching this
because I'm looking into getting an alternative, thanks for the video
Tyler Wilcox: The UP has been a really good fit for me. Cant give an honest opinion on
the Fit, but really love my UP. Jasons experience of it breaking is only a
single experience. Ive had mine and never an issue. The app is amazing.
Good purchase for me. Great video and appreciate a different outlook Jason.
Don't be dogging my UP!
Jason SurfrApp: Curious about activity wristbands? Don't know if you should get the new
Fitbit Flex or the Jawbone UP? Want to see a pair of my basketball shoes?
All those things and more in my Fitbit Flex vs Jawbone UP video review!
Craig Williams: Thanks for the video Jason. I plan on buying either one of them this
Christmas but not sure which would suit me best. I do more swimming than
running but was just wondering if the Fitbit Flex is waterproof and
wouldn't get damaged while I was doing laps of the pool? Keen to see how
much I improve when it comes to fitness this Summer over Christmas
Jason SurfrApp: This is version 2.
Jason SurfrApp: Hey Robyn, I have not taking the fitbit piece out of the band and kept it
in my pocket. I'll try that tomorrow and let you know how it goes.
Jason SurfrApp: Thanks Jay! Save up for the Flex, it's worth it.
getfitover40: I also wore both the UP and Flex and made a YouTube Video review and the
end result was that I preferred the Fitbit Flex over the Jawbone UP. Like
you I noticed that they seemed to track steps and miles about the same but
the Flex seemed to give me at least 500 more calories each day than the UP.
Did you see similar results?
mark lee: Great review, think I'll be getting the fitbit flex because I'm about to be
on my 2nd jawbone UP...terrible
Jason SurfrApp: Yeah, as I commented below to Francisco, sleep isn't the absolutely best on
either. The one thing about the UP that was great was the inactivity alarm
(if you sit on the couch for an hour, it'll vibrate and tell you to move).
That was a feature I do miss and hope Fitbit adds down the road.
Ishan Chatterjee: Thanks Jason! Super helpful!!!
Jason SurfrApp: What I found with the UP and the sleep alarm was that it didn't really
follow my sleep patterns, it just woke me up 30 minutes before my alarm
time. Almost always. And you could see different sleep patterns. Yes, the
UP does seem to track sleep a bit better, but what mattered most to me was
when to go to sleep and when to wake up, and both do that well.
jarikcbol: i've found that about 4 taps *on the side* of the fitbit flex band puts it
in sleep mode better than taps on the face. Also, if you have the band to
loose, it is harder to put in sleep mode.
Jason SurfrApp: Agreed. Although... The fit of the Flex is way better in my opinion.
Jason SurfrApp: Everything is not fixed now. The Jawbone UP I owned is the 2nd version (and
3 separate ones). Also, doesn't it seem a bit dumb not to have a
one-size-fits-all? Force people to know their size before buying? That's
just poor product design.
Kizzy Aqueelah: I just got on FitBit today and there is no scanner feature. However, I will
tell you this Jawbone's scanner feature is great but it's not perfect. Both
apps give you the ability to type in the name of the food and it is usually
already stored in their library for you to easily add it to your log. UP
also had the ease of adding restaurant dishes to your log because they were
also in the library. I'm sure FitBit has this ability as well. There will
be times where you have to manually log however.
2Much2Teach: Honestly, FitBit One is the better of them all.
יאיר פישביין: the best thing in this review is that from the beginning he says which one
he thinks is better...
Jason SurfrApp: Any specific reasons why? Have you tried the Fitbit Flex or Jawbone UP to
sydneytrains101: Jawbone up can be submerged to water
Jason SurfrApp: Sure does. Monitors how many times you wake up as well.
Tomicha Cassel: Considering buying the Fitbit flex for myself I've had a Fuelband and while
the watch is a nice feature I like that Fitbit syncs up with services like
MyfitnessPal. With the Fuelband I always had to do a ton of extra steps in
order to track my activity progress completely. It also tracks a few more
things than the FB, it's all about your needs really when it comes to these
Jason SurfrApp: A combination of football and basketball injuries as a kid. My nose always
Owahaha: I guess I will have to do the same thing. wake up at a right time by using
a sleep phase alarm is absolutely important.
Devon Lamoureux: You made some really good points. i never had a fitbit, but i respecfully
disagree. i do think that some things about up could be better, but the up
is still amazing, i personally just think that u might just of had bad luck
haha. my up had to be replaces once, but i am happy with it. the up comes
in 3 sizes- if u didnt know that and each size allows for more or less room
depending on conditions. anyways thanks! this video is deff amazing. i
enjoyed watchhing it! :-)
Sir na: Jason does a great job, I agree Edgy!
kaine2kii: The Fitbit One tracks stairs, however, doesn't track heart rate. One
downside to the "One" is that you wear it as a clip instead of a band which
is why i chose the flex. They cost the same but I don't feel comfortable
wearing a clip that could be lost.
Papeeshka: I think the light on the Jawbone Up is very bright. He is right about the
fit but I think he was wearing a size too small. The Jawbone wakes you
silently and tells you when you were still too long. I don't play sports
thought so I can see how that would be annoying.
Jason SurfrApp: Awesome to hear that Victor! I think these fitness bands have a little ways
to go, but the Flex is well on its way.
Jason SurfrApp: You're welcome! Thanks for taking the time to watch.
jlaudioking: My choice is made. Thanks
agulia09: is it bad that i chose the ONE because of the display showing me how much
ive walked...even though i think this flex a lot
Jason SurfrApp: Not at the moment.
Robyn Bair: Thanks :D
Jason SurfrApp: Do other devices track stairs and heart rate? I know Jawbone doesn't.
Jason SurfrApp: I was shocked to hear how poorly the Gen 1 UP bands did, but figured Gen 2
would be better. Apparently not. So far so good on the Flex and it does WAY
better (read: doesn't die) being submerged in water.
spiritflare: Thanks for this review
Pietro Martini: once?????it's enought..when i buy something once it's enought to think
thery're crap..3 or more as Jason said it's absolutely not acceptable.I can
not even consider a product like that.thank u Jason
Mark Dizon: thank you.... been waiting for your feedback
Jason SurfrApp: Cool! Glad I could help and I completely agree on worrying about the step
count being 100% accurate (how could it?). Let me know if I can answer any
other questions :)
Devon Lamoureux: OH! well message me tell me how everything goes! i just submitted some
stuff to the admins of UP and i might become an admin! i talked to some one
and they are gonna try to do what they can. they said expext an update very
soon! look at my last few food posts on UP! anyways the UP is better than
the flex and you know it haha plus u miss me and ur other teammates
asya2011: I would really like to monitor my calories and exercise to help me gain
weight, which one is better at monitoring food and stuff?
Jason SurfrApp: Yeah I haven't noticed any issues using it in water, unlike the UP which
dies in 1" of water. Thanks for commenting!
neek247: any issues with syncing to MYFITNESSPAL? i know jawbone has a major issue
Fitbit Flex vs Jawbone UP Review and Comparison4.8
out of 5