AeroForceOne: Elgato is better, but really who will notice the slight color saturation difference, and if you are doing commentary, who really is paying too much attention to the sound?
Ghost2341000: I have a GC1000 :/
lindex king: the color doesnt matter, because you'll probably have to color correct it anyway
Honky's Allerlei: @JAMESKNOWSGAMES. haha me too. Now I am sure what I want for christmas very good video
Treuze Bits: Helpfull, thanks man! :)
JAMESKNOWSGAMES: Thanks for doing this comparison video, I know what I want for Christmas now. ELGATO!
TheBumRumz: I'm getting a HD PVR, because it's the only game capture device my CPU can handle. I have Intel i3 Processor @ 2.30ghz so I can't even use the Elgato, HPVR2, & the Roxio HD.
jetawe gameTV: i found hd pvr 1212 for 65 plus shipping = 80 .. and still not sure about the quality
Gaming Maniac - HD Commentaries: Elgato editing sucks. HD PVR FTW
kamilrunekproductio: I have found a hd-pvr to 70 bucks ;-)
Frazoh: no h.d pvr 220 at best buy. 179 online order for elgato
athena mcgowan: 170 for elgato and 165 for pvr
RapidPuls: You idiot the most important factor PRICES
RapidPuls: Compare prices
SkulleeyDreams: Bye Pvr Hello Elgato
iPlayiOS: I'd agree with Koala... freak. -_-
Kreepy Koala: I regret getting a PVR now...
SoA RATBOY: The ergo to is mine!!!
Gameplay and Talk: Great, in-depth comparison. I think I'll be picking up the Elgato.
On a side note, for anyone curious about cheaper alternatives, I'd say avoid them. I snagged a Roxio Game Capture HD, and the thing has provided me with nothing but problems. Spend the extra money on something like the Elgato or HD PVR, it seems like you will get your moneys worth (although going by this video, it seems the Elgato is the ideal of the two choices).
Watson Leah: Also like avermedia live gamer portable support 1080p 60fps and amazing pc free mode.
Elgato Game Capture VS Hauppauge HD PVR REVIEW5
out of 5