TheBushwooky: Battlefield 3 should not even be a consideration for this list...this
coming from a die hard battlefield fan.
Cheese Cat: Battlefield 3 should be nowhere near this list.
TheAnthypass: "Top 5 Most Realistic War Games Ever" puts Battlefield in the video, where
people run around the whole map jumping and shooting at everything they
Jerome Narine: Imo war games won't be the exact thing you see in real life because of the
graphic images that the government ban from the public.
Jerry M.C.: this video is about realism right? well about 33 seconds into your video
you are jumping and running towards a man laying prone on top of a cat walk
on a massive skyscraper while he's shooting at you at point blank range and
you jump and move slightly to the right and shoot him with a hip fired
joe john: Battlefield 3 is realistic? HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHahaha
Micheal De Santa: COD is not as realistic as BF
Mrki Mash: If BF3 is realistic war game (not for graphics) I will cut my head off. In
BF3 you need hundreds of bullets to kill one enemy. The same is with CoD
and CS. The list should be: ArmA 3, ArmA 2, OF Dragon Rising, Ghost Recon
Advanced Warfighter and SWAT 4
JKrevy2294: No Rising Storm/Red Orchestra?
l0ud: Bad Company 2 is more realistic and funnier than the 3,in my opnion.When i
play bc2 i play for 7 hours non stop and it look like just 1 hour.
Kuebic: I'm surprised red orchestra/rising storm isn't on the list...
The Ohko: Battlefield shouldn't be on this list. And I know the Battlefield fanboys
will say read the description, freak that. This list is about realism.
Battlefield 3 is a great game, on of my favorite shooters of all time, but
realistic? No, in BF3, you can get stabbed in the neck and get revived over
and over again, you can get shot by a Barrett M98B (I believe it's a .338
or .308 I forget) in the stomach and just walk it off, you can get a
shotgun to the kneecaps and just say freak it and run away.
Willy bob: change battlefriend 3 out with red orchestra
ron weeslet: Where is Counter strike? Every spec you do will notify the enemies' intel.
Flashing and smoke positions, Recoil spray and call outs
enter.the.void: how is battlefield realistic? Do you even know what realistic means?
DavidAkhter: You are very wise for not including Call of Duty
eric racine: Arma 3 is awesome. Will try Arma 2 now. Did you know you can download a mod
to have all sorts of stuff and vehicules parachuted down to you :) Good
pocolish: BIG PLUS FOR THE SONG IN THE INTRO!!! it doesn't fit very well but the song
is just great!
lgmarrick: nice reading skills 0:50
Antoine Bacon: There was a game on PS2 I think...Where you couldn't actually shoot in it
but you would control two teams and make sure they where in the right
place.Anybody know the name of the game I've been trying to figure it out
for like the past two years.
Kelvin Nguyen: Tried playing operation flashpoint. Really fun games and it felt like i was
back in the box.... but i had to stop because of flashbacks i would get and
that would carry over to night terrors.... :(
HoodsCZ: Operace Flashpoint (Arma) is the best.
Vialpando 14: I'm a lil late but I think Insurgency or Red Orchestra should be replaced
cyberdaemon: Run and gun ruins pretty much any realism all together. Also firefights
should be extremely long and ammo consuming. Often in real life firefights
can last for hours and hours. Also, its unrealistic to have soldiers always
die from few shots. Its not easy, but its possible to get multiple shots to
a chest from AK-47 and survive. Also, not everyone dies immediately after
being shot - sometimes it takes long time before they bleed out. You also
shouln't be able to aim properly when under fire.
cassius969: I dont care about the realism. Simulations are much more engaging than
games where you run through a corridor pretty much.
arsnakehert: Not sure about you guys, but I think Rainbow Six 3 - Raven Shield is fairly
realistic, despite its age and the stupid AI. I wish they would make more
Rainbow Six games like the old ones. I know R6 Siege is going to be really,
really good, but I think it's more
*what-Counter-Strike-should-have-been-in-the-first-place* than Rainbow Six.
Alfio Rosario Di Mauro: Well done. I love your way of doing a top X. You place the name and
position of the game on the bottom, so one can always know what he's
watching. Very well, man. I agree with you about the list, love these games
John Smith: Ill tell you right now, battlefield is not realistic, at all, under ANY
marine6889: Insurgency, Red Orchestra, the first Operation Flashpoint (which is now the
first arma), the first couple Ghost Recon games, Delta force 1, Full
Spectrum Warrior, Rainbow six, SWAT, Project Reality mod, VBS, The navy
seals games on ps2. None of them are on this list?
Daniel Velez: Arma 3 takes place in greece
Nobody: Red Orchestra is more realistic then Arma because if you get shot in the
hand you drop your gun if you get shot in the leg you slow down plus
realistic fall damage.
gaminglittleshit: What about Insurgency???
José María Moreno Castro: NONE of them are realistic, because in reality, bullets drop at a certain
distance. In reality when your enemies are far you have to aim the sky to
reach your objective. In these "realistic" games your objective can be in
Mars, and if you aim the head from the Earth, you will have a headshot...
Kaleb Manuel: Just have a question. Has anyone on here that is commenting ever been in
the military or been in a real combat situation?
Maka Kioa: battlefield bad company 2..still the best in the bf series
VlogOffNAM: this is only 3 games.. Arma 2/Arma3, OPFP, Battlefield 3.
MP Productions.: 5th is battlefield 3? >:C Dislike >:C
Allan ball: most of these games are not realistic besides bf3 were's red orchestra 2
its one of the most realistic war simulators it even surpasses arma in most
places the only thing it dosent have is destructible environment on the
scale of battle field other wise most realistic
MsGangstercity: I know that is a mod but, Project reality should be here
Nambu Power: Rising storm & Red Orchestra 2 and Insurgency... Better!!!
Steve Xassassin: You clearly did not do any research or try to even find a good realistic
war game (could be a mod). Try Project Reality, its pretty good. Probably
the best game i had a true squad experience.
Logan Walker: Where is red orchestra 2
august schroer: Brothers in Arms should be # 1
Delta One: At lest you did not put Battlefield4 because I thought that game would be a
grate milsim game but not any more lol
Leonhard Rimmer: And what is with Red Orechesta 2 ?
socca blau: where the freak is counter strike global offensive? even the old cs 1.6 had
better realistic recoil than any bf or cod game
Eino Kostiainen: Has everyone forgot the operation flashpoint cold war crisis
Alec jones: Insugency should be somewhere on that list...